During  Instructor  Strikes,  Principals  Put  to  Test

During Instructor Strikes, Principals Put to Test

By Anne Rowe for DPS board, March 6, 2019

Teacher  Dina  Suarez  shouts  at  a  rally  with  other  instructors  in  front  of  City  Hall  in  Oakland,  Calif.,  last  month.  Principals  have actually  been  tasked  with  keeping  schools  open  during  the  continuous  strike  in  that  city.

Teacher Dina Suarez shouts at a rally with other instructors in front of City Hall in Oakland, Calif., last month. Principals have been charged with keeping schools open throughout the continuous strike in that city.

—Jeff Chiu/AP

Tough balancing act when school is open

Since the beginning of the year, teachers have already gone on strike in Los Angeles, Denver, West Virginia, and Oakland, Calif.

In 3 of those strikes, principals were charged with running their structures while instructors were out on the picket line. In Los Angeles, they were expected to teach classes while juggling regular duties—a task that already keeps most principals occupied for more than 60 hours a week, on average.

The decision to keep schools open is putting principals in a bind. Numerous school leaders are previous instructors and may highly support their teachers’ calls for greater pay, more education financing, and additional counselors and social employees. However they have a task to keep students safe and make sure that they are learning.

“I desire to emphasize that the primary’s task, basically, is to make sure children are safe and are informed,” stated Judith Pérez, a retired principal in the Los Angeles school system and previous president of the Associated Administrators of Los Angeles, which represents the district’s principals and other administrators. “And they have to have a favorable environment—and that indicates supporting instructors. So, it’s challenging on all levels. They were actually worried by the situations and feeling extremely much alone and separated in handling it.”

So provided the needs on principals throughout these emergency situations and intrinsic stress between supporting their striking personnel and supporting their task to keep trainees safe and finding out, what can districts do to make school leaders’ jobs more manageable throughout a strike?

Close Schools, If Possible

Ernest Logan, a former primary in New York City who now serves as president of the American Federation of School Administrators, stated districts must close schools when teachers are striking if they are not “safe and safe.”

It’s a “farce” to tell the public that there will be significant instruction when the majority of the mentor personnel is on the picket line and principals are expected to balance both administrative and classroom teaching tasks, he said.

Los Angeles Unified kept its schools open during a six-day strike in January. That prompted the principals’ union to ask the district to shut down schools 2 days into the strike. The union had gotten a number of problems, including one from a principal who encountered expletives from picketing instructors while trying to get in the building. Other principals emailed about inadequate personnel.

Denver likewise kept schools open throughout a instructors’ strike last month. On the first day, a student at East High School sent out a video to the Denver Post showing students dancing in the corridors, and students painted a chaotic scene to the paper. And Oakland schools stayed open throughout its first teacher strike in more than 2 years, though the principals’ union advised the district to close schools. As the Oakland strike wore on into its 6th day late last week, only about six percent of trainees were showing up for school, according to regional media accounts.

The United Administrators of Oakland Schools revealed its support for teachers, and 75 principals signed a public letter support their needs, including higher pay for teachers and more state education financing. More than 2 dozen principals boarded a bus to the state capitol in Sacramento the day prior to the start of the strike, to lobby lawmakers for more moneying, consisting of forgiving a $36 million state loan to the district dating back to 2003.

Principals manned schools with fewer trainees in Oakland on the strike’s first day. Principals’ union president Lauran Waters-Cherry, and executive director JoAnna Lougin, stated in a statement that the district ought to “abandon the notion that trainees can find out, and schools will function without expert teachers, and the supports of our therapists, psychologists, curators, speech pathologists, social employees, early youth and adult education teachers.”

Logan concurred.

“I believe that we must close schools, if it’s not a safe and protected environment,” he stated. “All we are doing is babysitting those kids, that’s what we are doing. There is no significant instruction going on.”

Be Transparent About Why

Since significant direction is not likely, districts ought to be sincere with parents and the neighborhood about why they are keeping schools open: Since schools are frequently the just location where some kids get 2 meals a day and a warm location to stay, Logan said.

“The concern the public requires to ask, ‘If we are not having direction, then why did we have the schools open?’ Since there is a higher social need more so than education[al]” need, he stated.

Districts also have a effective reward to remain open during strikes: millions of dollars are at stake. When schools are shut down, financing tied in part to typical everyday participation is lost.

Respond to Altering Dynamics

Districts can think that they have actually dotted all their I’s and crossed all their T’s as they prepare for the work interruption, but extremely few things ever go according to plan. They must be able to respond in the minute to feedback from principals.

While Los Angeles Unified worked with 1,400 substitutes and sent out 2,000 district administrators to aid principals, the assistance staff members and substitutes were not evenly dispersed. Some schools had too many administrators, while others did not have enough assistance, according to the local administrators’ union.

Principals grumbled about the long work days—they were showing up at school at 5:30 a.m. and leaving later on than they normally would. Personnel was stretched to the limitation.

“The working conditions were untenable before the strike. The scenario is now impossible. Knowing is not occurring. Schools needs to have been closed,” one principal composed to Juan Flecha, the president of the Los Angeles administrators’ union.

The schools remained open for the period of the strike.

Keep Principals in the Loop

As district agents, principals are the main conduit of information from the main workplace—to students, parents, and the wider neighborhood—and they must walk a fine line in what they state, even when they are not constantly privy to the information of the negotiations.

During a strike, they frequently have to assure moms and dads that schools are safe. However extremely often principals absence crucial details that moms and dads desire to understand, like how long the strike will last and when teachers will return to school.

Union leaders suggested that because principals should keep the trust of their parents and the neighborhood, they shouldn’t be required to parrot the central workplace’s talking points.

District officials must offer principals precise information, as much as is legally permitted—not just talking points—during the strike. And those messages must be conveyed in writing to principals and provided to them prior to instructors walk out.

Pérez stated that a standing committee that sets guidelines for what principals need to know and do during a strike would go a long method to alleviate the anxiety and stress.

Pérez experienced 2 strikes during her career in Los Angeles, and she recalled that during the 1989 teachers’ strike, the district sent communications to school administrators that included pointers on what to do in various scenarios and contacts to call in certain scenarios.

“I think what uses in LAUSD uses as much anywhere else there is a strike, where principals need to be clear on what is expected; what to communicate to parents; what to state to worried neighborhood members; how to make sure the safety of the kids and the personnel members in the school; what they do if they have a concern, whom do they call; how do they offer with an emergency situation, with concerns and responses,” Pérez stated. “And that requires to be supplied to them well in advance. It’s merely because it’s just a different situation from what they do on a everyday basis. And they requirement to feel like they can manage it.”

Pay Principals for Their Additional Time

If schools are open during strikes, principals should show up.

They are barred from striking in lots of states, and they can’t disobey a direct order from their superintendents without consequences, Logan said.

In many cases, principals do not have any recourse. They could file a complaint versus the district for altering working conditions, however that might only lead to discord and does not address the underlying conditions that led instructors to walk out in the first location, Logan said.

As such, principals should be paid for the additional work and additional hours they put in before and during the strikes, said Pérez.

Principals in Los Angeles reported spending weekends and nights prior to and throughout the strike to prepare lesson plans for classes they had to teach.

The payment will not be a significant amount of loan, but “it’s a indication of respect and gratitude for those who dealt with very difficult situations on behalf of the district for no thanks or appreciation,” Pérez said.

“And that goes a bit in the instructions of providing that acknowledgment and support.”

Vol. 38, Problem 24, Page 8

Published in Print: March 6, 2019, as During Teacher Strikes, Principals Put to Test

Back to Top Back  to  Top